top of page

DATA & OPPORTUNITY · RESEARCH & SCENARIO MODELING

What could society gain if more people left incarceration prepared to contribute?

Millions of decisions about education, skills, employment, and public safety are shaped by people and systems that rarely share the same information. ProtoMetanoia examines one practical question: could better connections among personal motivation, useful training, documented labor demand, and credible employment produce measurable benefits for individuals, employers, victims, and communities?

Before asking what is possible, define who is being counted.

FACT

1,254,200

People under state and federal prison jurisdiction, year-end 2023.

“The calculator uses only 1,254,200. We do not add prison and jail counts together. A year-end population is not the number of people released in a year, and none of these population counts is a measure of training readiness or employability.”

FACT = source-reported figure; EVIDENCE = findings within study methods; MODEL = arithmetic from disclosed assumptions; FOUNDER OBSERVATION = personal experience informing a research question, not population-level evidence.

FACT

658,700

People in local jail custody, midyear 2024.

FACT

68%

Unconvicted share of local jail custody, midyear 2024.

“Unconvicted is a legal status, not a finding of innocence.”

FACT

7.9 million

Jail admissions during July 2023–June 2024.

“Admissions are a flow, not unique people or simultaneous custody.”

FOUNDER OBSERVATION

One practical barrier exposed a larger question.

While incarcerated, founder Stanislav Osherov sought education and training that could help support productive work following release. Welding stood out as a skill with a recognizable occupation and measurable outside demand. The experience raised a larger question: When someone is motivated to change, what stands between that motivation and a credible opportunity to contribute?

That question is not answered by wages or prison population counts alone. It requires examining the path between willingness, training, qualifications, actual hiring, and durable work.

Opportunity is a process, not a promise.

The stages below are a research framework for thinking about opportunity, not a guarantee of outcomes.

An honest model must show the obstacles between a modeled worker and an actual job. This pathway is a research framework, not an operating service or proof of future success.

Motivation & readiness

Barrier: motivation is variable and difficult to assess; no universal readiness. What might help: transparent readiness assessment and voluntary planning. What would we measure? Who is ready to start and why?

Access to education

Barrier: program availability, enrollment, materials, timing, and eligibility vary. What might help: transparent access and needs assessment. What would we measure? Access, enrollment, and documented barriers.

Demonstrable skills

Barrier: completing a course is not the same as demonstrating industry-relevant competence. What might help: assessment, recognized credentials, portfolios. What would we measure? Demonstrated competence and credential completion.

Legal & practical eligibility

Barrier: licensing, conviction-related restrictions, occupational safety, identification, transport, release conditions, geography. What might help: early individual eligibility screening; never claim universal eligibility. What would we measure? Candidates meeting job-specific legal and practical requirements.

Employer confidence & hiring

Barrier: screening policies, lack of verified work evidence, employer liability perceptions, actual skill fit. What might help: verifiable skill records, employer partnerships, documented expectations. These are PROPOSALS, not current ProtoMetanoia programs. What would we measure? Documented employer consideration and hiring outcomes.

Retention & contribution

Barrier: employment can fail without housing, transport, workplace support, accountability. What might help: track retention, earned income, employer outcomes, community impact, adverse outcomes. What would we measure? Those outcomes, without inventing rates.

FACT

People under state and federal prison jurisdiction, year-end 2023.

FACT

People in local jail custody, midyear 2024.

FACT

Unconvicted share of local jail custody, midyear 2024.

Unconvicted is a legal status, not a finding of innocence.

FACT

Jail admissions during July 2023–June 2024.

Admissions are a flow, not unique people or simultaneous custody.

“The calculator uses only 1,254,200. We do not add prison and jail counts together. A year-end population is not the number of people released in a year, and none of these population counts is a measure of training readiness or employability.”

Real work, measurable demand—and real entry barriers.

Welding

May 2025 median annual wage: $53,750

  • Projected annual openings 2025–2035: 40,300
  • Projected employment growth 2025–2035: 2%

Technical preparation and on-the-job training; not necessarily direct entry at median pay.

Electrician

May 2025 median annual wage: $63,190

  • Projected annual openings 2025–2035: 72,700
  • Projected employment growth 2025–2035: 9%

Apprenticeships and frequent licensing requirements; apprentices usually earn less.

HVAC/R

May 2025 median annual wage: $61,010

  • Projected annual openings 2025–2035: 40,600
  • Projected employment growth 2025–2035: 11%

Education/training and sometimes certification/licensing; local conditions matter.

Plumbing & pipefitting

May 2025 median annual wage: $63,800

  • Projected annual openings 2025–2035: 42,000
  • Projected employment growth 2025–2035: 7%

Apprenticeships and frequent state/local licensing rules.

Industrial machinery & millwright

May 2025 median annual wage: $64,100

  • Projected annual openings 2025–2035: 51,900
  • Projected employment growth 2025–2035: 14%

Maintenance/technical preparation; safety, aptitude and employer requirements.

Machinist

May 2025 median annual wage: $58,750

  • Projected annual openings 2025–2035: 30,400
  • Projected employment growth 2025–2035: -1%

Apprenticeship or on-the-job training; openings and growth refer to machinists plus tool-and-die makers combined; median pay is machinists specifically.

Openings ≠ open jobs for everyone. BLS national annual openings describe broad hiring and replacement flows. They are not job offers, a count of positions for former prisoners, or permission to enter a restricted trade.

Mixed Trades in the model is the unweighted mean of these six medians: $60,766.67. It is an arithmetic convention, not a real BLS occupation, observed wage distribution, occupational placement mix, or expected starting salary.

Did you know? The detail changes the meaning.

FACT · 68% Unconvicted

Who is in local jail? Midyear 2024 BJS data shows 68% of custody is unconvicted. [Source: BJS Jail Inmates 2024]. Explanation: This is a legal status and does not equate to prison-program eligibility. What it does NOT mean: A finding of innocence.

FACT · 7.9M Admissions

How many people enter jail? 7.9M admissions July 2023–June 2024. [Source: BJS]. Explanation: This counts physical entries (flow) over a year. What it does NOT mean: 7.9M unique individuals or the number of people in simultaneous custody.

FACT · 72,700 Openings

Are electricians in demand? BLS projects 72,700 annual openings 2025–2035. [Source: BLS]. Explanation: Includes replacement and growth nationwide. What it does NOT mean: Specific job offers or reserved slots for returning citizens.

FACT · 30,400 Openings

What about machinists? 30,400 annual openings 2025–2035 despite -1% change. [Source: BLS]. Explanation: Combined machinist/tool-and-die projection while the wage shown is machinist-specific. What it does NOT mean: A projection for apprenticeships.

EVIDENCE · 43% Odds

Does education work? 2013 RAND/OJP higher-quality studies found 43% lower recidivism odds. [Source: OJP]. Explanation: Statistically significant reduction for participants. What it does NOT mean: 43% fewer crimes or a ProtoMetanoia prediction.

EVIDENCE · 28% Odds

What is the impact? 2018 strongest-design studies found 28% lower recidivism odds. [Source: RAND]. Explanation: No overall employment advantage found in this sample. What it does NOT mean: A job guarantee or current national employment rate.

EVIDENCE/FACT · 33%

Jobless post-release? 33% of the linked federal 2010 release cohort had no formal employment over 16 quarters. [Source: BJS]. Explanation: Emphasizes a dated federal-only linked cohort. What it does NOT mean: A current national employment rate.

FACT · $47,162

Cost of custody? $47,162 FY2024 federal incarceration-cost benchmark. [Source: Federal Register/BOP]. Explanation: This is federal only, not a national average. What it does NOT mean: An automatic saving; this figure is excluded from the model.

FACT · Policy Signal

New pathways? DOL 2026 RESTART includes reentry employment in skilled trades and manufacturing. [Source: DOL]. Explanation: Strategic federal policy signal. What it does NOT mean: ProtoMetanoia validation, financing, or partnership.

FACT/EXPLANATION

Entry vs Median? One-year median wages are not entry wages. [Source: BLS]. Explanation: BLS notes electrician apprentices earn less than the median. What it does NOT mean: A fabricated salary; no specific apprentice pay is claimed.

Demand extends beyond any one trade.

Broad economic signals indicate deep workforce needs in infrastructure and manufacturing, though demand alone does not overcome access, qualification, and regulatory barriers.

Navy & NIST Requirements

The Navy projects a need for 250,000 skilled workers over a decade, while NIST CHIPS targets 90,000 technicians and 100,000 construction workers by 2030. [Source: Navy/NIST].

GAO & BLS Production

GAO notes shipbuilding workforce gaps while BLS reports 1M annual production openings through 2034. [Source: GAO/BLS].

DOE identifies shortages in mining and recycling; DOL 2026 RESTART targets advanced manufacturing pathways. [Source: DOE/DOL].

What research supports—and what it does not.

2013 RAND/OJP: 43% lower recidivism odds and 28% higher odds of employment for vocational participants. 2018 Bozick/RAND (57 studies): Strongest designs confirm 28% lower recidivism odds but no overall employment advantage. Education may contribute to lower recidivism, but education alone should not be treated as a guarantee of employment. That gap is precisely why ProtoMetanoia is interested in connecting credible skills to actual employer demand and removing documented practical barriers.

Accountability for past harm and prevention of future harm are compatible aims. Claims about benefits to victims must be supported by valid outcome data. We do not convert historical research percentages into specific crimes prevented, victims protected, or dollars saved. Jurisdictional differences, cohort timing, and the difficulty of capturing informal labor create necessary limits on these research findings.

Probability vs. Odds: Probability measures event likelihood; odds compare likelihood of occurring versus not. These benchmarks reflect historical study groups, not individual forecasts.

Incarceration has a measurable cost. That does not make it an automatic saving.

  • This is a federal-only benchmark and does not represent a national average or state-level cost. Training does not shorten a sentence, and no marginal budget savings are automatically captured by reducing recidivism. Therefore, incarceration costs are strictly context and are excluded from all model savings calculations.

Don't take the numbers on faith.

Source Register: [BJS, Prisoners in 2023 / Jail Inmates 2024], [BLS, Occupational Outlook 2025-2035], [RAND/OJP Research Meta-Analysis 2013/2018], [BOP FY2024 Cost Data]. Definitions: Jurisdiction; Stock; Flow; Median; Odds Ratio; Federal Cost Benchmark. | Baseline Table: Mixed Trades Median Scenario: Share | Workers | Payroll | Receipts; 5% | 62,710 | $3.81B | $0.90B; 10% | 125,420 | $7.62B | $1.81B; 25% | 313,550 | $19.05B | $4.52B; 50% | 627,100 | $38.11B | $9.04B. Baseline reference last verified September 25, 2026.

CONCLUSION

The point is not that everyone leaving prison can or should enter a particular trade. The question is whether society can better identify motivated people, build credible skills, remove unnecessary barriers, and measure lawful employment and public-safety outcomes with the same rigor used elsewhere in the economy. ProtoMetanoia is investigating that question—not claiming to have solved it.

bottom of page